Saturday, April 11, 2015

Yik Yak: What you should know, what you can do if you need to, and why it's complicated.

A few days ago, a friend talked to me about YikYak.  I had heard of this before but had never really checked it out.  I knew that it was a platform for potential cyberbullying because The Bully Free Alliance of York Region of which I am a member, has spoken openly about the potential danger of the app which operates on the promise of anonymity.  But, when we looked at the app that afternoon the only thing that stood out was, "Poop is poop spelled backwards."  I had no idea that one day later, I would lose sleep over some of the posts on the app.

What is Yik Yak?

Yik Yak is a social media app where users can "yak" anonymously. As is the case with other social media, the app in and of itself is not "bad".  One student I talked to about it said she liked to see what students at different universities were saying on campus. Yik Yak does, in fact, have pretty explicit rules about its use, but the lure of anonymity makes it fertile ground for mean-spirited individuals to engage in offensive behaviour.

The premise is that you sign up for this service, enable location services, and then you can get a live feed of what everyone within a 1.5 Km radius is saying around you--completely anonymously.  Few, if any adults are in the space, so you can imagine what might happen.

If you disapprove of a post, you can "downvote," but if you can "upvote" it as well. The up and down votes cancel each other out.  If there are 5 "down votes" the message will disappear.  The messages with the most "upvotes" rise to the top.


There has been much written about the app in the US. At USC, one editor urges that we get rid of Yik Yak completely.  Diana Graber of the Huffington Post has an interesting post about it, as does the Washington Post's Caitlin Dewey, "How do you solve a problem like Yik Yak?"

At one of our schools, YikYak got completely out of hand the other day.  And though some students would "downvote" comments so they disappeared within minutes, there were a plethora of offensive comments posted with several "upvotes".

Students and teachers who were targeted were completely demoralized and upset. Understandably, the teachers and administrators who found out about it wanted IT to shut it down and I in truth, as I worried about the welfare of students targeted, in that moment I did not disagree.

What we learned about Yik Yak and inappropriate use

A more effective mechanism, we learned, is to have YikYak apply a geofence  to suspend the account if there is evidence that there are posts made by minorities or that the app is being used inappropriately.  This is what would appear if the account was suspended:



Yik Yak worked with administration to ensure that a geofence was put up--though this process takes anywhere from 24 hours to 3 days.  These steps  may provide support for administrators or Guidance Counsellors who notice that YikYak is being used offensively:
                                                                                                                                                                              (emphasis added)
Here is the contact information for Yik Yak Support http://www.yikyakapp.com/ in case you need it.

A few other things Yik Yak told us:

-if a post is flagged multiple times, it is sent to our moderation team. If you flag a post, the user who created it will not know that you flagged their post, however, if they are suspended, they will receive a notification about their suspension.

-Yik Yak cannot disclose any user information without the proper documents from law officials.

The federal Stored Communications Act, 18 U.S.C. § 2701 et seq., restricts Yik Yak’s disclosure of user account information without the lawful consent of the account holder or unless authorized by a properly issued warrant, court order, or subpoena. As a result, Yik Yak can only respond to requests for user account information that are received directly from a law enforcement agency pursuant to appropriate legal process. If you are aware of an emergency situation or other criminal activity, you should immediately contact your local law enforcement officials.

Guidelines for law enforcement officials seeking information about Yik Yak user accounts are available on the website at: [ http://www.yikyakapp.com/legal/ ]http://www.yikyakapp.com/legal/. Please have law enforcement contact us following these guidelines.

What the school did...


Administrators let Guidance and Chaplaincy know about the app and the comments made on it as it was clear that some students would need the support. There was an announcement made and a few teachers posted in the app, which in some ways made it worse.

The principal called for an assembly of the President's Council (the students who represent each of the Councils in the school), where he asked them what they thought should be done to address the situation.  As in any situation like this, often the students posting offensive things are in the minority, and with the situation out of hand, it was clear that these students wanted to ensure that they became part of the solution.

What the students said...


So much more than we could have anticipated as they engaged in some genuine dialogue about what could be done.  Here's a summary:
  • Many students implored us to shut the app down completely
  • Other students argued that if you shut the app down,  there are other apps that operate in the same way (they referenced Whisper and Ask FM) 
  • Others made the comment that if the Board blocked the app, students would just use their own data.  
  • One student made us aware of the "flagging" mechanism which can only be seen if you go into the comment itself. 
  • Others suggested that they spread the word and go into the app to post silly comments and to counter-act some of the negative ones
  • One young woman suggested that teachers be more vigilant with the no cell-phone in class policy.  
  • Many students wanted to into their classes and talk about the issue with them
  • Most of them agreed that the week before, there had been nothing objectionable on the app, and that most likely next week it would be not newsworthy again. 
In the end, the student action plan was that while school administration and IT worked on blocking the app, students would..

1.  Flag posts which were inappropriate and identified users
2.  Post on the app in more positive ways, ensuring that anyone who was targeted was supported and/or complimented and encourage their Councils to do so as well.
3.  Speak to their classmates about the situation.

Administration empowered the students to address the problem and the students took on the responsibility willingly and with much empathy, but there will need to be much healing and support for the school community as a result of this incident.


What I did as a parent...

Being so affected by this incident, I got our family (my two teenage daughters) to download the app and we read some of the posts together.  There was nothing really objectionable.  In fact, many of the posts in our geographic area were silly:
"I'm still scared of thunder and I'm 18"
"It's awesome to have really good conversations with my dog"

I asked them what they would do if do if they saw something mean or inappropriate.  My older daughter said she would downvote it so it would disappear as quickly as possible "so the person wouldn't feel bad."  Now she could have just been saying that because we were having this conversation. But we were having the conversation.
And then she said, "This is kind of stupid actually"...and deleted the app.

But yesterday, my daughter re-installed the app and I was horrified. 

My inside voice screamed, "How dare you?  Delete that app right now!" My outside voice calmly asked why she would do that when she knew about the horrible things that had happened in the app and that clearly I was so affected by the events that happened.  Her response to me was interesting. She said that in our area the posts are silly and funny.  She said, "Don't worry mum, if I see something inappropriate, I'll downvote it or report it."  She even asked me to look at it with her.

And despite every fibre in my being that was screaming at me to get her to delete it, I didn't (for now) because the posts in our area really aren't inappropriate.   Will I be extra diligent about checking up on her in that space? Absolutely.  But, letting her keep the app says I trust her and I want her to keep talking to me about the world into which I have so little insight as an adult.  Besides, now I know exactly what to do if there is something inappropriate or dangerous happening.

A Very Complicated Issue


So often we think of something like this as very black and white, but there are so many layers here to consider.

One of the students with whom we spoke was very forthright in his comments to us about how adults sometimes oversimplify things like this.  While we tend to speak about "good students" and "bad students"posting, he thoughtfully suggested that a very good student who might be needing to vent, might use Yik Yak as a mechanism to do so and that to categorize "good" and "bad" is not entirely accurate or fair.

And if your adult voice is emphatic that having an online place to vent is just stupid and dangerous, you need to read Dana Boyd's book, It's Complicated, which might make you rethink the idea of how students today view privacy in their networked lives.

And then there is the issue of blocking apps by IT.  There is no question that this app needed to be blocked immediately in this case to ensure the safety and well being of staff and students being targeted.  And yet there is lingering doubt in my mind that blocking all objectionable apps is a real solution; a sentiment echoed by more than one of the students.  In this case, isn't knowledge power? Wouldn't an administrator, like to be able to go onto the app to see what activity is happening that might put students in jeopardy without it being blocked from view because in reality students would still be able to do all of this on their own networks?  Might we need to rethink this stance in order to understand the realm of social media a little better as educators?

Then again, if we don't block an app like this, is it reasonable to suggest that Administrators can be aware of and check all of the apps out there that might potentially cause this much damage? Who has time for that?  This issue alone took up the full attention of the admin team when we know that there are so many other issues that are important to the well being of students in a school.

Another issue that came up is to enforce the "no cell-phone in class" rule.  Does that really solve the problem? Everything I do in my job encourages the use of technology in class as it can provide so many opportunities for creativity and accessibility.  I'm not sure I could even teach a class without students using their cellphones for something (very few of our classrooms are in computer labs). This knee-jerk reaction does not seem to me the right course of action as it doesn't really even address the issue.

George Couros' who had just spent some time at our School Board, also really got me thinking about Digital Leadership  How can we better enpower our students? At what age do we start?  How can we better tap into student voice to help us navigate this new frontier?

And the administrator at the school posed some very interesting questions as well.  What are the legal supports in place?  Is the solution petition the government to make Bill 13C more robust to include comments as well as images?  You only need to look at the controversy surrounding this Bill to know that there is no easy answer here.

Isn't the bigger question, beyond technology and apps? How do we teach empathy to students and an understanding that an anonymous post can be just as hurtful--if not more so?  Shouldn't teaching students Catholic Character mean we teach them to be the same person online and face to face?

I have invited the students from President's Council to write a guest blog-post which I am hoping they will do.   I welcome your feedback and the sharing of your own experiences.







Tuesday, April 7, 2015

Shall we rethink Speeches?


Recently, I organized a successful EDTech day for teachers at my Board and instead of a Keynote, I took a chance and facilitated IGNITE presentations by our own teachers.  I got the idea from the ISTE conference which always has powerful and engaging IGNITE sessions. An IGNITE is basically 20 slides, 15 seconds/slide for a total of 5 minutes.  The topic?  Anything about which you are passionate.

As I prepared for my own IGNITE on being a Connected Educator, and then when a grade 9 student at one of our high schools agreed to present an IGNITE alongside her teacher, I began to think about this format as a great Oral Communication tool for students.

When George Couros (@gcouros) invited educators to post a teaching idea using #EDUin30 for week 1 (#EDUin30w1), using IGNITE to replace the speech--an oral communication task we've had our students do for the past million years--was the first thing I thought to share:

Why an IGNITE?

  • short and succinct
  • requires planning and practice
  • allows kids to express a passion
  • builds upon oral fluency and digital literacy skills
  • helps students create visual aids for their speaking
  • provides support for students with working memory issues
Get started with these resources.

The other day, a friend who was listening to our IGNITE presentations, was wondering the same thing:

If you're already doing this or if you are going to try it out in your class or school let me know, I'd love to hear how it goes.





Sunday, March 8, 2015

Reflections on a Successful EDTech Day for Teachers

Yesterday, we hosted an EDTech day for Educators at the York Catholic District School Board which was an overwhelming success.  Here are a few reasons why.

Skip the Keynote

Rather than have a Keynote speaker from outside of our District, we decided to try out an IGNITE session.  A few of us had been to the ISTE conference and LOVED the format. If you've never heard of an IGNITE, Check it out here. We put the invitation out to everyone and only got 6 teachers who were crazy enough courageous enough to come forward.  As the lead organizer, I led the charge, collaborated with the volunteers and then left them to their brilliance.  You'd be surprised at how difficult a 5 minute/20 slide presentation is to prepare!  One presenter said it was the hardest thing he'd ever done.

The result was more than we could have hoped--very different and unique perspectives and topics, and a truly motivating way to start the day!   Thanks to +MichaelWoodrow +Dan Bruni +Anne Ratchford Daniel LaGamba, +Dave Cheng, @MsMollyTL Theresa Penny for joining me on the IGNITE stage!


Student IGNITE presenter

When I met Sabrina, a grade 9 student at St. Elizabeth, whose learning journey brought her such immense confidence, I took a chance and asked her if she'd be willing to prepare an IGNITE as well.  Her teacher/coach Ms. Penney (who also volunteered to present one) helped her to prepare and rather than timing her slides, she controlled them on her own (less pressure).  It was an amazing way to bring student voice into the day and she did an amazing job!

I'm sure that next year, we'll have many more volunteers--both teachers and students--willing to present an IGNITE.

Teacher Facilitators

We created a Google Form and asked teachers from the system to lead sessions.  This year we had over 35 teachers come forward to showcase the innovative things they were doing in their classrooms.  What incredibly talented teachers we have working at our District!  Having them facilitate not only builds capacity of the teacher-leaders in our Board, but their ideas and experiences provide both inspiration and a practical starting point!   We had a great range of topics and various entry points for teachers anywhere in their journey of integrating technology.  Some of the sessions offered less about the "how" and more about the "why" allowing participants the opportunity to talk about important issues around access, logistics, equity, privacy, etc...

Board Level Support


We had full participation and involvement of many key personnel in our District.  Our Director of Education not only came to bring greetings, but she stayed and learned alongside her teachers.  We also had Superintendents of Curriculum, and the Senior Manager of IT @DarleneClaphamK12 support the initiative from the beginning, as well as actively participate in the day.  They have been instrumental all along in providing a vision and  moving our system forward in terms of technology enhanced, student-centered learning.

Push the Envelope a little


Although it was essential for us, to offer beginner opportunities for Google Apps for Education, iPad, and Desire2Learn as these are what make up our Technology Ecosystem, we also wanted to push the thinking a little bit.  There are some early adopters within our District, but for the most part, we are fairly slow to start with integrating Edtech in our classrooms.  Ideas such as Coding, using Twitter and Google +, Gaming in the Classroom, Flipped Classrooms, etc...are old-news to some, but for many of our teachers, they are brand new.  We made sure to include some of these workshops in the mix so that people can at least start to think about non-traditional ways in which to provide a student-centered learning experience.

We invited @MzMollyTL @Niecsa @GamingEdus to present an IGNITE and stick around to show teachers the power of engaging students through Minecraft.  We know that many teachers are excited to explore this further.

Other Musts

Learning Space

This year, we offered a place where participants can go to consolidate their learning if they need to.   We also promoted the idea of a Coffee EDU (an idea which I got from @DougPete this summer and which we saw in action at the Bring It Together Conference 2014).  Basically, people were encouraged to gather and talk about their passions, ideas, or concerns in an informal setting.   We left the cafeteria open all day for this dual purpose.   Although it did mean that some of the sessions may have had fewer participants, for people suffering from information overload  or who felt the need to connect with other educators, it was a great alternative.

Reliable Tech

Let's face it, there is nothing more frustrating than attending an EDTech day and not being able to connect your devices.  Choose a venue that will handle your needs!  We chose to hold the event at St. Augustine C.H.S., which has an excellent infrastructure.  We also had a dynamic duo behind the scenes ensuring everything went smoothly as well as IT personnel there in case things went awry.
Our Information Jedi (@gadgetqwn) took care of our Help Desk, and we lent out devices to people who came without one so everyone would have a hands-on experience.



Here is a link to our EDTech Site:  https://sites.google.com/a/ycdsbk12.ca/gafe-saturday-ycdsb/

If you are running your own EDTech event and would like to share ideas, feel free to connect with me!

Saturday, February 7, 2015

Google Art Project, Critical Thinking, and the OSSLT

I know what you're thinking--what in heavens name does the Ontario Secondary School Literacy Test (OSSLT) have to do with Critical Thinking or the Google Art Project?

One of the tasks of the OSSLT is for students to write a News Report.  They are given a title and a photo and need to make up the details in a formal news report.I contacted the Education Quality Assessment Office (EQAO) a few years ago expressing my dismay with this task.  My argument was that journalists don't even use the formalized report style the kids are expected to use.

The Educational officer responded to my query with the following information:
1) the news report is a writing activity that does not require excessive prior knowledge and thus works well in a timed (standardized test) environment;
2) because the task requires students to infer W5H about a picture before writing the report, it is a good gauge as to whether or not students can think critically and creatively.

While this does make some sense to me, for many students (especially for students who have issues writing tests or who have slow processing speed needs) this is an extremely challenging thing to do in a timed situation. But, for grade 10 students in Ontario who wish to earn a diploma, the OSSLT is a reality and so is the News Report Writing Task.  So how to we help our students with this task?

The typical way teachers try to support students to write this task is to have them write practice news reports.  Many teachers try to incorporate this task into their courses, while other schools have preparation booklets with the task in it.  This approach can be somewhat effective, but it can be boring and sometimes out of context for students.

How about just focusing on the critical thinking and creative part then? Combining  a strategy from the Critical Thinking Consortium with The Google Art Project allows kids to think critically, practice making inferences, and potentially delve more deeply into art.


Observation, Inference, Conclusion Chart


Garfield Gini-Newman, from the Critical Thinking Consortium engaged a group of teachers at my Board in an activity using the Observation, Inference, Conclusion Chart.  Essentially, he placed an image up on the screen and asked each group to agree on when and where the picture took place.  The result? We talked and argued for over 20 minutes.  Throughout the activity, Gin-Newman came around and did some "additive teaching" using statements like, "Did you notice....?"  "I wonder what that detail in the corner could be? "Hmm, I wonder if there would be a shadow there if it was 2 o'clock in the afternoon", etc...

O.k. Great for teachers--we love to talk!  But would students find such a task as interesting? Would they engage in conversation for as long?  I tried it in several grade 9 applied and academic classes and the answer is a resounding YES!  (We did provide students with sentence stems to help with their conversations, but they rarely needed them!).

The strength of the activity is the open-endedness, the fact that it builds inferencing skills, and that it really engages curiosity and critical thinking. It's also relatively low risk: students have to use details in the image to support their claims but otherwise, there is not real right or wrong answer. It can work in any subject and with any image that has enough detail to infer W5H.

Here's the graphic organizer I adapted: Click here


The Google Art Project


The Google Art Project is a resource where you can find millions of images to use in the activity described above.  I can find images that connect to any subject area and, as a bonus, will expose students to some of the most famous artists in the world.  I always hear teachers complain that students don't come in with any prior knowledge or culture-- well here's a great way to bring Art Galleries into the classroom.  Click here for a quick overview of how to use it.


Now of course students will need to organize their thoughts into actual writing of a news report for the task, but if we engaged students in regular critical thinking around W5H  and images, we are not just preparing them for that OSSLT task, but we will be helping them make sense of the world around them as well.



Sunday, October 5, 2014

RAN (Reading and Analysing Non-Fiction)


Recently, two of my colleagues (Michael Ball and Gina Micomonaco) reminded me about The RAN Chart--Reading and Analyzing Non-fiction.  Based on the work by Tony Stead, a RAN chart is a great starting point for an inquiry classroom!

The categories are:

Prior Knowledge (What I think I know)
Confirmed (I was right about this)
Misconceptions (What I couldn't prove)
Wonderings (Questions I still have)
New Learning (What I did not know)


Here is one they created for a Junior class:


What I love about the RAN strategy is that it encourages kids to delve further into a text and test out their theories.  It also encourages "wondering."

"Wisdom begins in wondering." --Socrates


I do like the idea of using post-it notes as students can move them flexibly from one column to the next, but you could easily create a Google Slide (one for each category) which students could use with the same flexibility.  I would show older kids how to use "revision history" in Google Slides to track their progress.

The real power of this strategy, to me, comes at the end of the process, where students track what they have learned about the topic.  The RAN chart and post-it notes become key artifacts of their learning.  Students could take pictures of the post-it-notes that they had created, and combine then images or key quotations from the text.  Students speak to what they were thinking at the beginning, how that thinking changed, and what they learned about the topic.

Students can use tools like Explain Everything, iMovie, Keynote/Google Slides/Powerpoint, Prezi, or Adobe Voice to present findings.

Like any graphic organizer, it is important to model first, then have students try it in partners, before moving to independence.

The RAN strategy, a very useful graphic organizer, has seemed to fall by the wayside in high school classes.  This year when I work with high school teachers and their students, I plan to use it!

Have you tried RAN in a high school classroom?  I'd love to hear about it!

Here are two excellent resources which provide further support and ideas:

 Adventures in Literacy post by Colleen and Stacy.  Their blog is chalk-full of helpful tips for reading based on Core Standards.

Making Shift Happen post by  Lorraine Boulos on using the RAN strategy for Inquiry based learning using the Wendats as a sample (Ontario Curriculum).




Saturday, September 13, 2014

Setting kids up for success

Many of us are two weeks into a new school year and with that comes the opportunity to think reflectively about what has worked and what hasn't.  Here are a couple of ideas that may help to create a positive learning environment and set the tone for the rest of the school year.

Have EVERY student create an IEP (Individualized Education Plan)

Image:  http://blog.enablemart.com/letsblogability/2010/06/what-is-an-iep-learning-about-ieps-individualized-education-programs.html

We understand that students who are accessing student services are legally entitled to an IEP, but wouldn't it be useful if all students communicated their strengths and needs to their teachers?  Not only might this be a great opportunity for teachers to get to know their students, but it would also eliminate the stigma of an IEP.  Heck, I wish I could give some conference presenters my own IEP!

How about creating IEPs on a Google Doc or Google Form so that it can be shared with teachers the following semester or year?
Sample IEP on Google Forms

Foster a Growth Mindset


"Without continual growth and progress, such words as improvement, achievement, and success have no meaning." Benjamin Franklin



I just returned from a two-day SIM session which used the Growth Mindset Theory as the underpinning of how we can achieve greater student success in Math in Ontario.  The theory has been around for a while, but it's worth mentioning because research supports that fostering a growth mindset works.

Some students (many of whom have been told they are failures in school since Kindergarten) don't believe that they can learn, that trying is futile. Undoing these beliefs takes persistence and a caring adult who genuinely believes every student in front of them can learn and who provides opportunities for growth and reflection.

So Teacher mindsets make a huge difference!  Do we already pre-determine our students' ability based on social, cultural, or genetic factors? Do we think we know in September which students will work at Level 4?  Do we refer to a group of students as "My Level 2's,  Level 4's?"  If the research shows that Growth Mindsets contribute to student success, then our language and actions as teachers has to reinforce the belief that the students before us can and will learn as a result of our teaching.

And it works!! We told a group of grade 9 Applied students that they would be better readers at the end of the semester, worked hard to give them strategies, asked them to reflect on which strategies helped them to be better readers, and guess what? At the end of the semester, they not only thought it to be true, but they performed better on the post-diagnostic.

Check out this video:

This simple anchor chart shared on Twitter by @Principal_EL reminded me about how important it is to ensure that students really believe that they can become better readers, writers, creators, etc...

I would actually have students sort a few sentences that reflect one Mindset or another and then create their own anchor chart.  




More information on Growth Mindsets:
Carol Dweck's article on Mindsets and Equitable Education
Jo Baler's work on Mindsets in Math
Brain Pickings Blog on Fixed vs. Growth Mindsets
You can even become a Mindset School.

ASK your students for Input and then LISTEN to what they say

Why not show kids the Curriculum expectations and get their ideas?  If we relinquish our "control" of what kids are learning, we may just be surprised at the results.  Perhaps not for the entire course (just yet), but how about for one "unit" or for 10% of the time?

I love Shelly Wright's three guiding questions:
What are we going to learn?
How are we going to learn it?
How will we share the learning?   

Her blog is a great starting point for any teacher looking to move to an Inquiry-based classroom.

In my experience, students who were able to choose their own reading, tended to be more engaged in the activities.  So obvious but so often we dictate what kids read, when they read it, and what questions are important about the reading!

Focus on Self-Assessment and Goal Setting


In their book, "Knowing What Counts, Self-Assessment and Goal Setting," authors Gregory, Cameron, and Davies provide practical ideas and templates for practising self-assessment so as to improve self-directed learning in students.

I especially love the simplicity of some of the strategies and the reproducible templates, particularly the idea of "proof cards": Teachers give students cards that have a word or phrase printed on it such as "favourite," "potential," "perseverance", or "improvement".  Students select ONE proof card, a word, and an example from their own work that provides evidence or proof of that word or phrase, as well as reasons to support their selection.  It's a great way for students to recognize their growth.

Regularly asking students what strategies work and don't work best for them, also helps them to realize that they can actually control how they learn best.  Tech tools such as Google Forms, Padlet, Socrative are quick ways a teacher can gather and share regular input from kids about what they know.

Here are a couple of examples of student self-assessment forms I've used in English Class:

Monday, June 30, 2014

There's something about ISTE

I am constantly in a line (for food, for a session, for the bathroom), and the Wifi is quite frankly worse than it is at home, and yet the experience of ISTE is one that is incomparable to any other.

Where else, would you be in contact with about 15,000 other like-minded educators who know that teaching can look differently?  That student-centered learning yields remarkable results, and that technology can help students to create and share in ways we could have never imagined?

Kevin Carroll (in his keynote address today) said that the moment he committed himself to the path he had chosen, providence set in; everything he needed to be successful just fell into place.

And so it is with ISTE, I think.  Once you commit yourself to being a part of this amazing energy, that is bigger than anything you've experienced before,  you can't help but go back to your classroom and commit to transformation.

Even though I know it will take weeks to digest all of the information that has come my way, I think there is no better PD in the world and no better opportunity to connect.  Because even though we have Twitter and Google Plus and other collaborative virtual tools, we thrive on the  face-to-face connections that validate us as a part of something bigger,  and that dispel the belief that we're just outliers in our lives back home.

Cheers to all you amazing educators in ATL! Looking forward to Philadelphia in 2015!

Friday, May 9, 2014

It's time we try something different in English class

On Tuesday and Wednesday of last week, I had the privilege of listening to Will Richardson speak about bold classrooms and what they could look like.  He told over 500 teachers at YCDSB that we need to suspend our nostalgia for what school looked like in the past, because that world no longer exists.  He challenged us to look at the courses we have been teaching for the past 10 years and ask ourselves whether or not they are fundamentally the same now as they were then.

His challenge to our group of 500 teachers and administrators over the two days he spent with us:

Transform your classrooms into places of passion, purpose, and participation, where kids are using technology to do real work for real audiences, solve problems, make things that matter, and change the world.


These ideas are not really new to me.

And yet, I was perplexed and couldn't sleep after that first presentation.  I came to the realization that in the four years that I've been in my role, I hadn't really impacted as great a change as I would have hoped: that nostalgia for what school should look like, very much impedes any real transformation in Education today.

Without adequate time to process my learning, I became immersed in new learning at the Connect 2014 conference in Niagara Falls where I was able to meet and speak with so many like-minded educators.

The presentations and ideas of Michael Fullan, Shelley Wright,  Lori DeMarco, Peter Aguiar, Paul Yip,  Zoe Branigan-Pipe, and Jim Pedrich each with their own rich experiences and stories from the field, swirled together with the ideas that had been already tossing in my head, creating a tsunami.  I spent two days completely impressed by the innovation of teachers and students in pockets around our province.  And again, I felt like I hadn't been enough of an "instigator" in my own professional life.

For me, the easiest and most difficult transformation can happen in high school English class--especially our applied courses.


Why?

English teachers are passionate and hard-working and they spend so much time and energy trying to connect stories, novels, plays, and poetry to students' lives.  They change their syllabus regularly to include contemporary texts and include current events.  They spend more of their time providing feedback to students on their papers than any other discipline.

And yet...

"Students are increasingly bored in school and teaching bored students is especially challenging."
                                                    --Michael Fullan, Connect 2014



Students in applied English courses are generally disengaged, unmotivated, and disinterested. They don't feel connected and don't feel that the course is relevant.  Plagarism runs rampant and students spend more time reading summaries of texts on the web than they actually do reading the texts. And generally speaking, technology doesn't help because students are not impressed by technology in and of itself.  And let's face it,  submitting a literary essay electronically is not too different from submitting a word-processed print copy.

When I think about why so little has changed in terms of the way we teach English over the past 20 years, I can only conclude, that as Will Richardson suggests, it is nostalgia.  You see, unlike other Ontario Curriculum documents, no content is prescribed in the Overall Expectations for Language Arts or English.  Students are required to read, write, listen, speak, and create and understand media for a variety of purposes and a variety of audiences.

That's it.  Lots of examples (from 2007 when the document was created), but no "thou shalt" statements.

And yet, across the province (and I know because I ask everyone I meet) English high school courses look like variations of this:  poetry unit, non-fiction unit, short story unit, novel study, Shakespeare. Our texts are still primarily selected by teachers and delivered to a whole class at the same time, and our physical classrooms still look very much the same.  And while that may have been an effective way to organize a course ten years ago, this is not working for many of our students: especially those in applied courses.


Could we find a more modern approach?
What opportunities exist for inquiry-based or project-based learning in an English class?
How might we better equip our students to read and understand the world in which they live and into which they will graduate?


You could say that because I haven't had my own classroom for four years (I am in classrooms co-teaching regularly, but that is not the same), I am idealistic and out-of-touch with the realities of a modern classroom today.  And so, I am going to get into a classroom in September to reimagine English for modern learners. 

Are you with me?  Let's create a "Modern Learning Movement" in English! I'd love to hear your ideas!


Saturday, April 26, 2014

Using Garageband in the Classroom: Working, Saving, and Sharing


So now that I'm actually in the classroom, co-teaching with a fabulous English teacher and using Garageband with students, there are a few things we've learned that may be useful to you. 
N.B.We are using shared devices. 


The Assignment

Students were asked to take two poems and the song lyrics of one song that share the same theme and create a "Mash Up".  The result will be an entirely new poem which they will recite and put to music using GarageBand.  This is a senior English class, so what the teacher is looking for is a fairly comprehensive explanation of student choices including an analysis of poetic devices.  You could definitely do this same assignment with younger students, with the focus being oral/reading fluency, rather than analysis. 


Step 1:  Student work periods


If possible, assign the iPads to partners or triads so that they can continue to work on their creations on the same iPad for more than one day.  Working within the App is ideal for editing, and we found one work period to be insufficient time.

Step 2:  Moving your GarageBand creations off a shared device

Option A:  
Airdrop the GarageBand creations from shared iPads to a teacher iPad or to a teacher Macbook--this is ideal if your students still need to edit.
Option B: 
"Open In" Google Drive (as per these video tutorial instructions)
Option C: 
Share to your Youtube Channel

Step 3:  Playing your GarageBand creations

For Option A:  
If you are not using shared devices, or if you've Airdropped your creation, you may play directly from the GarageBand App
For Option B:  
If you have saved the device to Google Drive, you will need to be in the Google Chrome App to be able to listen to the creation on your iPad.  OR you can access your creation on a desktop or laptop provided you have Reeltime, Quicktime, etc...  
**OR download Drive Tunes from the Google Chrome store to play directly from your Google Drive account.
For Option C:
Play directly from your Youtube Channel

If you teach English, and want to assess students's speaking skills (Oral Communication strand) as they work, feel free to use or modify this Assessment Checklist we created.

I can't wait to share the student samples!  They are working so hard and LOVING it.  

Monday, April 21, 2014

A fresh look at Assessment


Just before the holiday weekend, I had the honour of participating in a workshop led by Sandra Herbst on Assessement.

The first thing she did impressed me the most.  She introduced herself to each participant (well over 100 teachers and administrators), looked each of us in the eye, and sincerely welcomed us.

She later went on to say that in her school district, there is an expectation that EVERY STUDENT is greeted by name and welcomed EVERY DAY.  It made me think about that quotation by Maya Angelou  about how people remember how you made them feel beyond anything else.  Sandra emphasized that many students in her District may only encounter a caring adult at school, not in their home lives.  It made me recall a time in the not-so-distant past when  I would dive right into the day's lesson just as students arrived so that we could "cover the material."  What a missed opportunity!

It's so simple and yet so profound.  I think about what an impact it would make on the climate of a classroom and a school if we took a few minutes every day to ensure that our students felt welcome and valued.

I've learned that people will forget what you said, people will forget what you did, but people will never forget how you made them feel.       --Maya Angelou

Here are a few other ideas that resonated the most with me:


  • "assessment" comes from the Latin to "sit beside"-->we need to spend more time observing and conversing with our students; prompting their thinking and giving them feedback about next steps--not just testing them and moving on.
  • "evaluating" is about placing a judgement on work which, more often than not, stops the learning
  • technology is a tool that can help us to find out more about what a student "knows" that goes beyond "pen and paper" tasks
  • some tech tools can help us to capture student conversations--she highlighted Quick Voice Pro and Voki--I have used Educreations for this purpose as well
  • being transparent about what is expected (Success Criteria) is crucial to students knowing how to achieve success
  • if we focus on learning, students will achieve far better on standardized tests than if we focus on "preparing" kids for tests
  • understanding a student (learning needs, social needs, etc...) will help teachers make decisions that will help move learning forward
  • it is essential to establish what "quality work looks like" --> then, when students submit their work, it is important that they identify what parts they believe to be examples of quality in their own submission (Use notes in Google Slides or Comments in Google Docs)
  • A "visual continuum" can help empower student to create quality work: Basically the teacher posts several examples of work that become incrementally more sophisticated--a student can identify where his work is on the continuum and what more is needed to get to the next stage--there are no marks or levels at all on the examples, and students are told that even beyond the "best" example, there is other criteria that could make it better. It is important that the examples are not always posted worst to best.


Throughout the workshop we saw videos of teachers and students learning together, we engaged in some high-impact activities, and had excellent discussions at our table.  I will certainly be taking this information into my daily practice.

Much of this work echoed the research done by Carol Dweck in the area of Growth Mindsets.

More information about Sandra Herbst can be found here.  She can also be seen on Twitter @Sandra_Herbst

Tuesday, February 18, 2014

Let's get our kids talking!!

Reading and Writing float on a sea of talk.

--James Britton

More and more research is suggesting that academic conversations are foundational for other literacy skills.  Read this excerpt from a book called Content Area Conversations for a good foundational understanding of how important academic conversations really are.

Here is a poster I created with sentence stems that help kids get started or move them along when they have nothing to say.  I love to get students to add to it and make it their own:


















These are a few of my favourite tools (insert Sound of Music theme song here) that may just get your kids talking more in class:

Face-to-Face Talk


1.  Save the Last Word for Me (Also called Final Word):  this is a great strategy to get kids talking and listening to each other.

2.  Grafitti:  This strategy gets kids up and moving and thinking and talking.  This is my favourite--I've never been in a class where this hasn't worked like a charm.  As a pre-reading strategy, I take excerpts from the story or article students are about to read; the level of understanding increases dramatically when students have had time to think and discuss.  If you have access to technology, you can use this strategy in combination with an Interactive Whiteboard or Whiteboard app (see Educreations below)

3.  Say Something:  I first learned about this strategy when I read Kylene Beers' book, When Kids Can't Read.  This is so simple and effective at any age.  It can be used for fiction, non-fiction, a video, an image; just about anything you want kids to talk about in class.

Virtual Talk

Face to face talk is extremely important, but sometimes technology breaks down the barrier and allows for students to participate when they wouldn't normally.

1.  TodaysMeet: simple but so awesome for getting kids to start a "conversation" and have their voices heard.

2.  Padlet:  Just a blank "pad" which give students the opportunity to post an idea, a link, etc...Students watch the pad get populated in real time.

3.  Voicethread:  I really love how this tool allows kids to listen to the perspective of others before adding their own.  I also like the different options--audio, video, text.  I don't love that there is a subscription fee after your initial free ones,  but if you're creative, you can let your free ones go a long way.

4.  Educreations (or ShowMe, DoodleCast, Explain Everything):  Any simple whiteboard tool that captures students speaking.  We have access to iPads so it's great to use with partners.  I find they need something upon which to anchor their conversations so I have them take a picture (image or text) and speak to specifics.

Tuesday, January 7, 2014

Chrome Extensions that are necessary for some and good for all

I attended a Google Bootcamp with Learnstyle this summer.  There I met +D.J. Cunningham, a successful and dynamic entreprenuer who founded the company despite his dyslexia.  During our summer BootCamp, he showed us some valuable Google Chrome extensions that level the playing field for our students (not just those with learning disabilities).  Here are his recommendations, plus a couple of my own which I have been sharing with teachers in both elementary and secondary schools.

These extensions can be found by launching the App icon (top right hand corner of your Google sign-in page)


 and then clicking on "Chrome Store" icon.  Be sure to search for extensions rather than apps.  Once downloaded an icon will be added to your toolbar for easy access.

Read and Write for Google
The free version has a read aloud and translator for the web and Google docs, as well as a dual-color highlighting tool.    It also allows users to choose their voice and voice speed.   The premium subscription has talking and picture dictionaries as well as word prediction software.   This extension is perfect for struggling readers and writers, as well as English Language Learners and I love the fact that it works seamlessly with Google Apps for Ed.

Simple Dictation
This is a very simple to use dictation tool that allows students the ability to speak in order to compose an email or search the web.

iSpeech
This Google extension is an easy-to use text to speech tool that will basically read the web for you.  Unlike Read and Write for Google, there is no integration with your Google Drive.  There is a pause option and a speed control, as well as a variety of different human-voice options.

Ginger
The Ginger extension (not to be confused with a variety of cat-related apps in the Chrome Store)is a spelling and grammar checker that offers corrections based on context including commonly confused words.

Diigo
Diigo is both an annotation app (sign up for full version at www.diigo.com as well as an extension which allows you to annotate (sticky note, highlight) and store resources you collect on the web.  It's the perfect place for students who have trouble managing resources and finding all of their research notes.

These tools help to level the playing field for our students who struggle with reading and writing.

If you have any more, please feel free to share!


Other awesome extensions I use daily include: Evernote webclipper that works with my Evernote account; Pocket for those great articles I won't have time to get to until later; and Bitly for shortening URLs. 

Friday, January 3, 2014

Using Tech tools to promote Academic Conversations and Student Voice


@picswithastory December 31st, 2013
Thanks to a MISA Grant, I am able to work with a group of English Department Heads and teachers from across six secondary schools in our Board.  Our focus is to improve Oral Communication: specifically, to promote student voice,  academic conversations, and metacognition in grade 9 applied English courses.  Because of a Board-wide technology initiative, we will have access to iPads for our project.

We began by isolating a few tech tools that might help us.  We narrowed it down to the following:
Today's Meet;
Educreations (similar to Doodlecast and Show Me);
Garage Band;
iMovie.

TodaysMeet

Though students don't actually speak when using this tool.  We chose this as a great entry point for all students to have a voice.  A teacher could draw upon the entries of shy students who rarely participate orally.   This is a risk-free way to begin to value the contributions of all students.

Educreations (or a similar Whiteboard app)

We decided upon educreations because we wanted to capture student conversation as it was happening.  We purposely selected the tool for its simplicity.  The idea here is that students are given prompts and are to use the tool to record their ideas and opinions.  Then, more importantly, students listen to themselves and assess their skills and set goals for next time.

Both of these tools have worked very effectively.  We have co-taught a lesson using a poem about homelessness as a springboard.  We will begin our next planning phase using both GarageBand and iMovie.

 

Garage Band

Though the perfect tool for music lovers and creators alike, the audio recording feature makes it an ideal tool for students to practice their speaking skills and reflect on them.  Click here for a previous post about using Garage Band for reading fluency.

iMovie

The teachers believe that if students have a media product about which to speak, they may be more successful when presenting orally.   Students will use iMovie to practice speaking formally as their task will focus on an oral news report and an editorial.  The teachers also wanted students to present live, so they will be presenting their selected current event and introducing their iMovie.

I am very much looking forward to seeing the results of this planning and learning.

Saturday, December 21, 2013

Using Garage Band in Language Arts/English

We recently showcased Garage Band to our 21C teams and it is incredible.  Our friendly neighbourhood Computers in the Classroom Consultant (who taught everyone how to use it wonderfully), cited the fact that at the height of their career, The Beatles had equipment that could only mix 4 tracks, while the free version of Garage Band allows the creator to use 16!!

And though the main focus was on music creation, I couldn't help but wear my Literacy hat to think about  how you could use Garage Band in Language Arts (Ontario).  The Oral Communication strand is all about speaking for a specific purpose and audience and the Reading strand speaks to "reading fluency."

Struggling readers continue to be struggling readers because they don't practice.  They don't practice because they don't enjoy reading.  My daughter is a perfect example.  She is my reluctant reader.  She would rather scrub toilets than read anything.

When we were preparing for the presentation, I asked her to recite a stanza of a poem for me and to help me put it to music.  She absolutely refused until she realized I was talking about Garage Band and then, low and behold, she rehearsed a poem by Langston Hughes and recorded and re-recorded probably close to a dozen times.  I was amazed!  And that's when it hit me, kids would practice their reading fluency and oral communication skills without complaint if we had them do it in this context.

Other ideas for using Garage Band for Literacy and Language Arts:

-turn a story into a radio play
-retell an Aboriginal tale or a short story
-create a prayer to music
-teach rhythm and rhyme using the free instruments
-have a poetry slam-- partners or triads mix poems with music around the same theme
-use for student self-assessment of oral skills

Our Math consultant immediately thought about using Garage Band for fractions...

Like many tech tools out there, their original purpose can be re-purposed in the classroom to amazing results!


When I explored the internet for other ideas, I found this great post by  @edapps that showcases some great ideas for using Garage Band in Classrooms.




Sunday, November 24, 2013

The Real Power of Technology: Authentic learning experiences

Today, teachers have opportunities to connect with experts in a way that we have never been able to do before.

I had the pleasure of participating in a NFB virtual conversation between a Mr. Rob Cannone's grade 6 class, David Suzuki--Canadian Environmentalist, and Adam van Koeverden--Olympic kayaking gold medalist, as they discussed water conservation and sustainability.  The students had previously posed and recorded  their questions and were selected to ask their question to the panel.





I walked in just as the webcast began.  The students were riveted--they didn't even seem to mind that this was all happening while their peers were out for lunch recess.  At first, as they sat there listening for several minutes, I thought, wow, this isn't very student-centered...The students basically listened to the various questions and answers posed by a number of elementary and secondary schools from across Canada.  

But when it was time to ask their question, I noticed the students move forward a little more and hold their collective breath as their class rep read their question.  And then lean in further to catch what David Suzuki said in response.  At the end of the webinar, Mr. Cannone asked them to record their big ideas and additional questions on Today's Meet and then I saw magic happen.  

The class came alive!  


They had caught every single word!  When I asked a few students about the experience they were enthusiastic and thoughtful.  Their answers showed an excellent connection to the Science curriculum and the big idea of water conservation and sustainability.

At the end of the webcast, David Suzuki posed a challenge to students to take action.  He suggested they "think globally and act locally," "celebrate water," "create an awareness campaign", etc...  When Rob and I debriefed after the lesson, he was really excited about where this might take his class moving forward.

You can call it project-based learning, inquiry-based learning, the connected classroom...  I call it powerful and engaging.  

Bravo @Mr_RCannone and all of the terrific and innovative teachers like him who use their PLNs and connections to make learning meaningful for kids.




Tuesday, October 29, 2013

PD Gets A Bad Wrap: 8 characteristics of Effective PD



I had a great conversation with a group of educators a few weeks ago about education technology and something a young teacher said struck me.  It is the same feeling I get sometimes when I read Twitter posts about how people feel that they are not really benefiting from PD.  Though I definitely agree that traditional PD falls short of the mark,  I don't agree that all PD is dictatorial and/or useless.  I also think there are some amazing teachers working in School Districts and they are trying to yield positive change from the inside out.


I think that PD can be be effective if it is learner-centred.  Here are 8 characteristics of PD that have made for successful learning in our District.

1.  Collaboration 

Where possible, include more than one Department in the planning and facilitating of a workshop or session. For our 21C sessions for example, I brought my Secondary Literacy lens to the table.  My super-fantastic team members?  Special Education technician, Computers in the Classroom Consultant, IT Manager, Superintendent of Curriculum.  Though it was sometimes hard to meet in the middle, we challenged each other, grounded each other, and learned from each other--this teamwork really helped to make the sessions awesome.  We also used Google Presentation and shared our game-plan with Consultants from other Departments, a few teachers, and Senior Admin.  Though this level of collaboration isn't always possible, it is definitely a good idea to get another perspective whenever possible.  We also recognize that we have brilliant educators with valuable insights to share.  Whenever possible, we plan to pull these "experts" in and collaborate with them as well.

2.  Knowing what you are trying to accomplish


When planning, be sure to articulate your learning goals and continue to check to ensure that you are meeting these throughout the session.  People appreciate knowing what they are going to learn and feeling like they accomplished something in the end.

3.  Knowing your audience and honouring their knowledge


Prior to running a PD session, find out who your audience is and what they want out of the session.   We sent out a short survey so we knew what prior knowledge teachers were bringing with them.  We also asked teachers what they were hoping to learn which helped to inform the direction of our sessions. Every morning, we would review the responses, anticipate issues and decide how we needed to modify the topic, our approach, or our pace.

4.  Differentiating Instruction


After you learn about your audience, ensure there are different entry points for various skill levels. Just like in a classroom, a teacher should provide adequate challenge and support, so too, should a PD session offer that same support and challenge.  If possible, groups can break out based on skill, subject, or age (of students).  We ensured that where there were teachers who already had student examples of the tech tool we were showcasing, got to share their expertise.  We also got these participants to help us support new learners.  In future sessions, we will empower these individuals to lead sessions.

5.  Providing a forum for feedback and questions


A simple backchannel like Todays Meet is a great way to encourage questions and the sharing of ideas.  This provides an opportunity for teachers to share their knowledge and ideas and seek understanding for questions that come up.  We try to answer all of the questions posed on Today's Meet at some point during the session.  We also had a hashtag for Twitter questions and ideas and of course had post-it notes handy just in case someone wasn't quite ready for the technology (note--even though we offered the choice, no one used a yellow post-it note--yay!)


6.  Making it hands-on and practical

If we would like our teachers to create opportunities for rich dialogue in a student-centred learning environment, then this approach needs to be modelled in our own PD sessions.  In our full day session, teachers engaged in conversation, critical thinking, and created and shared a movie trailer that consolidated their learning.  We provided open questions for discussion, resources, and "mini-demonstrations" throughout the day, but the time we spent at the front of the room talking or presenting was minimal.  We also built in time to share ideas for practical classroom implementation.



7.  Providing opportunities to consolidate learning

Reflecting on big ideas and new learning is an important step in consolidating understanding.  Wherever possible, give the opportunity to share and plan based on the day's learning--build it into the session time.     If teachers aren't given time to reflect, share, and plan for possible implementation at the end of the session, it is unlikely that they will find the time to do this later.
 

8.  Following up and Providing opportunities to go deeper

If there are lingering questions, be sure to answer them.  Provide a place (we use a Google Site) where teachers can get a copy of the resources and materials shared and where they can get additional information AND contribute ideas themselves.  Opportunities to go deeper through co-planning and co-teaching certainly help with implementation of ideas in the classroom.   We provided a mechanism for teams within schools to pursue their own inquiries (Student Learning Proposals) which may or may not be facilitated by Central staff.

Hmmm....this list can easily read:  8 Characteristics of Effective Teaching.